How Hours of Service Violations Can Strengthen Your Truck Accident Claim

A serious truck crash is never just about twisted metal and totaled vehicles. For many families, it means immediate medical bills, weeks or months away from work, and a future that suddenly feels uncertain. In the middle of all this, it can be hard to know why the collision happened or who should be held responsible.

One key piece of the puzzle is whether the truck driver and trucking company followed federal Hours of Service rules. When those rules are broken, it often reveals a pattern of pushing drivers too hard, prioritizing delivery schedules over safety, and exposing everyone on the road to needless risk. That kind of evidence can significantly strengthen your truck accident claim.

Understanding Hours of Service And Truck Driver Fatigue

Hours of Service regulations are federal safety rules that limit how long a commercial truck driver can be on duty, how many hours they can spend behind the wheel, and how much rest time they must have between shifts. These rules, enforced by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), are designed to reduce fatigue-related crashes by keeping dangerously tired drivers off the road.

For example, most property-carrying drivers are generally limited to 11 hours of driving within a 14-hour on-duty window, after at least 10 hours off duty, and must stay within weekly caps such as 60 hours over 7 days or 70 hours over 8 days. When these limits are ignored or manipulated, the risk of a catastrophic collision increases sharply. Fatigue can be just as dangerous as alcohol in terms of slowing reaction time and clouding judgment.

From a legal standpoint, proof that a trucker exceeded Hours of Service limits does more than show a technical violation. It can help explain why the truck drifted out of its lane, why braking was delayed, or why the driver missed obvious hazards. That story matters when insurers are trying to minimize what happened or blame other motorists.

How Are Hour of Service Violations Discovered

Most people assume that if a driver says they were “within their hours,” that must be the end of the conversation. In reality, experienced truck accident attorneys know that Hours of Service compliance needs to be tested, not taken at face value.

Today, many trucks are equipped with Electronic Logging Devices, or ELDs, that automatically track driving time. Those records, combined with other trip data, can reveal whether the driver exceeded their legal limits, skipped rest breaks, or manipulated their log entries. Attorneys work quickly to secure this information before it can be lost or overwritten.

Common sources used to uncover Hours of Service violations include:

• Electronic Logging Device data that shows actual driving and rest periods
• Fuel and toll receipts that conflict with the driver’s reported locations and times
• GPS and telematics records from the truck or fleet management system
• Bills of lading and delivery timestamps that reveal impossible schedules
• Inspection reports and prior citations for fatigue or logbook issues

When these pieces do not match the official logs, it is often a strong signal that the driver or company tried to conceal how long the truck was really on the road. That mismatch can become powerful evidence in your favor.

How Hours of Service Impact Liability in Your Truck Crash Case

In a truck accident claim, liability is about more than who hit whom. It is about why the crash happened and whether it could have been prevented through reasonable safety practices. Hours of Service violations are a direct window into those issues.

If a driver exceeded their allowable hours, failed to take required breaks, or operated on an unrealistic schedule, that can be strong evidence of negligence. When a trucking company encourages or tolerates such behavior, it may face its own liability for unsafe policies or failure to monitor compliance. Courts and juries often view these violations as signs that a company put profit ahead of safety.

Key ways Hours of Service violations can affect liability include:

• Linking fatigue to the crash when the driver made obvious errors or failed to react in time
• Demonstrating negligent supervision if the company knew or should have known about repeated violations
• Supporting claims for punitive damages in extreme cases where safety was knowingly ignored
• Expanding insurance coverage by bringing the carrier’s higher limit policies squarely into the case

In short, these violations help connect the dots between a paper rule, a tired driver, and the real world harm you suffered.

Trucker Compensation Methods Can Lead to Hours of Service Violations

Truck drivers work hard, often under intense pressure to deliver loads on time, regardless of weather, traffic, or delays at loading docks. How they are paid can play a huge role in whether they feel forced to push beyond safe Hours of Service limits.

Many drivers are paid by the mile rather than by the hour. When pay depends on miles covered, every traffic jam, detour, or slow unloading eats into their income. Some drivers respond by skipping breaks, “stretching” their day, or adjusting logs in order to keep the truck moving. If a company quietly rewards this behavior with better assignments, it can become the unspoken norm across a fleet.

Compensation structures that can encourage violations include:

• Per mile pay with no realistic time allowance for delays and mandatory rest
• Unpaid loading, unloading, or waiting time that drivers must “make up” on the road
• Bonus systems tied to tight delivery windows, regardless of conditions
• Dispatch practices that penalize drivers who refuse overly long runs

When a crash occurs, attorneys look closely at these pay systems. If a company’s own incentives encouraged a driver to cut corners on Hours of Service, that points directly to corporate responsibility, not just an individual mistake.

Evidence That Links Fatigue to Your Injuries

To strengthen your claim, it is not enough to show that a rule was broken. Your legal team must also connect that violation to the harm you suffered in the collision. This is where detailed investigation and expert analysis become crucial.

Accident reconstruction experts study skid marks, vehicle damage, and event data from the truck to determine speed, braking, and reaction times. If the evidence shows that a reasonably alert driver should have avoided the crash, but this driver did not, it supports the argument that fatigue played a central role. Medical experts may also explain how the nature of the impact fits with a failure to brake or steer in time.

Helpful forms of evidence can include:

• Witness statements about the truck drifting, swerving, or failing to slow down
• Video footage from dashcams, businesses, or traffic cameras along the route
• Prior incident reports involving the same driver or company and fatigue claims
• Company emails or dispatch records hinting at schedule pressure or rule-bending

When this evidence is tied back to proven Hours of Service violations, your claim becomes more than speculation. It tells a clear story about how a tired driver, pushed too hard, caused your life-changing injuries.

How Insurers Defend Against Hours of Service Allegations

Insurance companies and trucking defense lawyers understand how damaging Hours of Service violations can be. As a result, they often work hard to downplay or reinterpret what the records show. Being prepared for these tactics is essential if you want to protect the value of your claim.

Insurers may argue that even if a violation occurred, it did not actually cause the crash. They may point to weather, other drivers, or road conditions as the “real” problem. Sometimes they focus on technicalities, such as arguing that a driver was off duty at a certain time or that a missing entry was just a clerical error, not proof of systemic abuse of Hours of Service rules.

An experienced plaintiff’s firm responds by gathering as much independent data as possible and by working with experts familiar with trucking practices. When your legal team can show that the stories, logs, and electronic records do not line up, it becomes much harder for the insurer to dismiss the violations as harmless or irrelevant.

The Importance of Acting Quickly After a Truck Crash

Time is critical in any truck accident case, especially when Hours of Service violations may be involved. Electronic Logging Device data, GPS records, and internal company communications may only be stored for a limited period. Once lost, that information is often impossible to reconstruct.

Prompt legal action allows your attorney to send preservation letters, request logs and electronic data, and begin working with experts while the trail is still fresh. At the same time, your medical care and daily life continue, which is why having a legal team that handles the details can be such a relief. You should not have to choose between focusing on your health and protecting your legal rights.

For families in Nebraska and Iowa, it also helps to work with a firm that understands local courts, regional trucking routes, and the specific ways that interstate carriers operate in and around Omaha, Lincoln, Council Bluffs, and surrounding communities. Local knowledge can make a very real difference when it is time to present your case.

Why Choose Hauptman O’Brien For a Truck Accident in Nebraska or Iowa

Cases involving Hours of Service violations are not routine car crash claims. They require a strong understanding of federal trucking regulations, access to qualified experts, and a willingness to go toe to toe with national carriers and their insurers. Hauptman O’Brien has built that level of experience over decades of representing injured people throughout the Heartland.

Our firm brings nearly three centuries of combined legal experience to personal injury and truck accident litigation. We treat each case as a serious turning point in a client’s life, not as a file number or quick settlement opportunity. That means detailed investigation, tailored strategy, and direct communication between you and your attorney. When we uncover dangerous patterns in a trucking company’s operations, we pursue full accountability, not only to compensate our clients, but also to help make our roads safer for everyone.

Contact a Truck Accident Attorney Today

If you suspect that fatigue or Hours of Service violations played a role in your truck crash, you do not have to figure out what to do next on your own. The trucking company and its insurer are already working to limit their exposure. You deserve a team that is equally focused on protecting you and your family.

Hauptman O’Brien represents truck accident victims throughout Nebraska and Iowa from offices in Omaha, South Omaha, Bellevue, Lincoln, Sioux City, and Council Bluffs. When you contact us, you speak directly with a truck accident attorney who will listen carefully, explain your options, and outline a strategy based on your specific situation. Your initial consultation is free, and you pay no attorney fees unless we obtain a recovery for you. If you are ready to learn how Hours of Service violations could strengthen your truck accident claim, reach out to our team today.